3l - A better modifier based keyboard layout

Three Layout, more commonly called 3l, is an alternative keyboard layout designed for efficiently typing both English text and computer programs. 3l is modifier based, so many of the keys which would normally be accessed on the top row (with numbers on QWERTY) can be accessed on the main part of the keyboard.

To give you an idea on how much this layout can improve your typing efficiency, compare typing distance of George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four to other common layouts:

QWERTY	10.4 miles
Neo 2.0	6.3 miles
Antibracket (which this keyboard layout was based on)	6.3 miles
Dvorak	6.2 miles
Colemak	5.9 miles
Workman	5.8 miles
WULY (my old layout)	5.6 miles
ARENSITO	5.3 miles
3l	4.9 miles

Typing distance is not the only factor that 3l optimizes for. 3l helps increase hand alternation, reduce bottom-to-top row jumps, decrease lateral motion, and also strives to be easy to learn.

See the docs directory for more images of the layout.

Testing the layout without installation

On Linux (using X or Wayland):

• If you have xkeyboard-config 2.27 or later: 3l is already installed on your system. Just type setxkbmap us 3l or use your window manager's settings to adjust your layout.

• If you have xkeyboard-config 2.26 or earlier: clone this repository and run this command:

  setxkbmap 3l -print | xkbcomp -Ilinux/xkb - $DISPLAY
  

To return to QWERTY keyboard layout, type setxkbmap us.

On Windows, compile and run the provided AHK script. Your keyboard layout will return to normal when the script exits (in system tray). You may also be interested in toggling the layout.

On 9front, copy the file 9front/3l to /sys/lib/kbmap/3l. You can use kbmap(1) to switch between layouts.

Installation

Linux

To set 3l as the default keyboard layout for your system, add a section to your X11 configuration:

$ cat /etc/X11/xorg.conf.d/99-keyboard.conf
Section "InputClass"
        Identifier "system-keyboard"
        MatchIsKeyboard "on"
        Option "XkbLayout" "us"
        Option "XkbVariant" "3l"
EndSection

systemd has the localectl utility that you may optionally use to maintain this configuration file.

If you don't have xkeyboard-config 2.27 or later

Place the linux/xkb/symbols/3l file in your system's symbols directory. This is typically something like /usr/share/X11/xkb/symbols. You'll need the configuration to look a little different:

$ cat /etc/X11/xorg.conf.d/99-keyboard.conf
Section "InputClass"
        Identifier "system-keyboard"
        MatchIsKeyboard "on"
        Option "XkbLayout" "3l"
EndSection

Mac OS X [2]

1. Install Karabiner Elements
2. Copy the macosx/karabiner.json file to the ~/.config/karabiner/ directory.
3. Select the 3l profile from Karabiner Elements.

[2]	Get off your hipster butt. This can be used to refer to "OS X" and "macOS" as well.

Windows

There are two implementations of 3l for Windows, a simple AutoHotkey script located in this repository, and the more advanced ReNeo also offers a configuration for 3l. Depending on your needs, you may want to check out the ReNeo driver for advanced customization options.

AutoHotkey

Place the AHK script in your "Startup" folder.

To toggle between 3l and your system layout (e.g., QWERTY), press both Alt keys at the same time.

ReNeo

See the ReNeo repository for install instructions.

9front

Copy the file 9front/3l to /sys/lib/kbmap/3l. You can toggle the layout with kbmap(1).

To set the layout on boot, add it to your plan9.ini(8):

% 9fs 9fat
% cat /n/9fat/plan9.ini
  ...
  kbmap=3l
  ...
% unmount /n/9fat

Ensure that the file ends in a newline. You will also need to rebuild your kernel, following the instructions under FQA 5.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens if I have to use someone else's computer and all they've got is QWERTY?

Short-term use of someone's computer with QWERTY is usually a non-concern. Since most keyboards have the layout printed on the key caps, most users of 3l don't have any issues surviving.

For long-term use (such as on a shared machine, or a school lab computer), applying the layout temporarily usually only takes a few minutes to setup and can help relieve some pains.

What happens if someone has to temporarily use my computer?

For Windows, see toggling the layout.

For Linux, most window managers provide a convenient way to toggle between layouts. If your window manager does not have that, just bind a key to run setxkbmap.

If anyone has some Mac OS X tips, please submit a PR. (I presume Karabiner makes this pretty easy.)

For 9front, use kbmap(1) to switch layouts.

How should I start learning?

The Klavaro Typing Tutor is configurable to multiple layouts (you can put in 3l as a custom layout) and is an excellent option for learning. You should start with the basic skills courses before the speed-typing courses.

Most users will recommend going cold turkey from your old layout when just starting to learn. This will help you focus on your learning, and learning survival QWERTY later is always an option.

How long does it take to learn?

Most users are able to accomplish survival typing skills (>20 WPM) within one week of starting to learn. Focusing on accuracy over speed during your first few weeks of learning will help you be successful, and you'll pick up the speed in the long run.

Will I forget QWERTY?

Most users seem to indicate that they lost some QWERTY skills while re-training their brain to 3l, but were eventually able to recover enough skills to survive in the long term.

Will I type faster than on my old layout?

Maybe. While most users report they are able to type faster than they could on QWERTY, the primary benefit of trying an alternative layout is in typing comfort and health. Many users enjoy reduced repetitive motions, and find typing longer hours less difficult.

Will I have to re-configure my text editor for the new layout?

3l was designed partly with keeping vanilla Vi-style keybindings somewhat sane in mind. If you find yourself using many systems and don't want to have to keep configuration in sync, you'll appreciate how easy it is to use Vi or Vim style editors with the default configuration. I personally use Emacs with Evil mode, and haven't had any issues keeping most of the Vi-style bindings in their standard configuration. That being said, if you find that some sort of rebinding with respect to 3l helps you, I'm curious to see what you've done. Maybe we can drop this in some sort of contrib/ directory.

I'm curious to hear if and what people do to work with 3l and non-Vi editors. Drop me an email or a PR :)

Is the symbols layer designed for a specific programming language?

The symbols layer is mostly derived from the Neo 2.0 keyboard layout, and to the best of my knowledge, was not designed with any specific programming language in mind. I've used it with everything from C-style languages, to HTML, to Haskell, to Python, and Lisp and have found that most every language benefits from the symbols layer.

What about using the layout on mobile?

Modern mobile keyboards (such as Gboard) tend to use machine learning algorithms for predictive input and autocorrect, and these algorithms were trained on QWERTY users. In addition, QWERTY's design of common bigraphs spaced far apart is incidentally a helpful design when using swipe typing. For these reasons, nobody has bothered with making a moblie version.

However, an Android or iOS version of the layout could potentially be useful for tablet typing. If someone with expertise in this domain wanted to implement this and submit a PR, that would be very much appreciated.

Help, I'm using Gnome on Wayland and can't configure it to use 3l!

Some rarely used keyboard layout variants are not available by default when you use gnome, 3l is one of them. To enable Gnome's visibility of the 3l variant run the following in your terminal.:

$ gsettings set org.gnome.desktop.input-sources show-all-sources true

Now 3l will be available through the keyboard configuration UI

Gnome Documentation

Community

Matrix Room

Join our Matrix chat room at #threelayout:ohea.xyz.

Mailing List

There is an email list for general chat about the layout. Please subscribe to the list. You can send mail to the list using the address:

[email protected]

You do not have to be a member to post, so feel free to reach out on this list with questions about the layout, even if you're not a user yet.

Users' Registry

This section lists people who have learned to type on 3l. Users who learn to type at least 15 WPM (that's what it takes to get past the initial learning threshold) on 3l can be added to this list. This list is included here so you can query typists to see what they like and dislike about the layout before you dedicate time to learning, or so you can reach out for learning tips.

• Jack Rosenthal (Me, who created 3l in the Fall of 2015)
• Josh Hoffer (who learned 3l in the Spring of 2017)
• Sumner Evans (who learned 3l in the Spring of 2017)
• Robert Zampino (who learned 3l in the Spring of 2018)
• Patrick Nichols (who learned 3l in the Fall of 2018)
• David Florness (who learned 3l in the Fall of 2018)
• Daichi Jameson (who learned 3l in the Fall of 2018)
• Jesus Nunez (who learned 3l in the Fall of 2018)
• Liam Warfield (who learned 3l in the Spring of 2019)
• Sam Warfield (who learned 3l in the Summer of 2019)
• Sam Sartor (who learned 3l in the Summer of 2019)
• Peter Rosenthal (who learned 3l in the Spring of 2020)
• Sean Gillespie (who learned 3l in the Spring of 2020)
• Uladzislau Khamkou (who learned 3l in the Fall of 2021)
• Samuel Clay (who learned 3l in the Spring of 2022)
• Liam Abell (who learned 3l in the Fall of 2022)
• Byron Sharman (who learned 3l in the Spring of 2024)
• Ivan Abramov (who learned 3l in the Spring of 2024)
• Jason Robinson (who learned 3l in the Spring of 2024)

If you learn the layout, feel free to submit a PR with your name added.