From 38caaf41ca5a2c032d49525ea2438f79b4a7233d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: LauraB-CWF <144256088+LauraB-CWF@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Fri, 14 Jun 2024 13:27:36 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 1/7] BULK-Updates-2024-06-13 (#519) * BULK-Updates-2024-06-13 Updates to crossings incorrectly assigned as 'Passable' * note cwf/wcrp specific nature of barrier status update for these two crossings --------- Co-authored-by: Simon Norris --- data/user_pscis_barrier_status.csv | 2 ++ 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+) diff --git a/data/user_pscis_barrier_status.csv b/data/user_pscis_barrier_status.csv index 693bad97..295a8ffd 100644 --- a/data/user_pscis_barrier_status.csv +++ b/data/user_pscis_barrier_status.csv @@ -1319,3 +1319,5 @@ stream_crossing_id,user_barrier_status,watershed_group_code,reviewer_name,review 197017,PASSABLE,LNIC,LB,2024-04-09,"This is a ford, PSCIS barrier_status = UNKNOWN, edit existing record in fix table to PASSABLE" 196200,PASSABLE,TABR,SN,2024-06-03,"Crossing has been remediated, see https://news.gov.bc.ca/releases/2020TRAN0099-001219" 196223,PASSABLE,TABR,SN,2024-06-03,Imagery clearly shows crossing has been remediated with a bridge installation +197664,POTENTIAL,BULK,LB,2024-06-13,Updated to potential barrier for CWF WCRP reporting +197665,POTENTIAL,BULK,LB,2024-06-13,Updated to potential barrier for CWF WCRP reporting From 82c62162659ba999fafdd9ace3aac4bd60065a57 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: LauraB-CWF <144256088+LauraB-CWF@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Wed, 19 Jun 2024 21:03:52 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 2/7] BULK-updates-2024-06-17 (#522) Addition of coho spawning habitat on stream with blue_line_key 360804115. --- data/user_habitat_classification.csv | 1 + 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+) diff --git a/data/user_habitat_classification.csv b/data/user_habitat_classification.csv index bbc49fe5..f78823e2 100644 --- a/data/user_habitat_classification.csv +++ b/data/user_habitat_classification.csv @@ -15294,3 +15294,4 @@ 360873822,22478,22509.83251,BULK,SK,spawning,t,LB,2024-06-06,Pacific Salmon Foundation,River sockeye 360873822,168869,170329.9685,BULK,SK,spawning,t,LB,2024-06-06,Pacific Salmon Foundation,River sockeye 360881038,0,280.2148356,BULK,SK,spawning,t,LB,2024-06-06,Pacific Salmon Foundation,Lake sockeye +360804115,652.18,852.93,BULK,CO,spawning,t,LB,2024-06-17,Pacific Salmon Foundation, From 50815accdca023130a044739e432c65c6f9d84c1 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Simon Norris Date: Thu, 20 Jun 2024 16:21:28 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 3/7] use cached DRA data and move dra download to monthly schedule --- jobs/load_monthly | 21 +++++++++++++++++++++ jobs/load_weekly | 18 ------------------ 2 files changed, 21 insertions(+), 18 deletions(-) diff --git a/jobs/load_monthly b/jobs/load_monthly index 1708a145..7f11b9ee 100755 --- a/jobs/load_monthly +++ b/jobs/load_monthly @@ -25,6 +25,27 @@ bcdata bc2pg -r whse_mineral_tenure.og_petrlm_dev_rds_pre06_pub_sp bcdata bc2pg -r whse_tantalis.ta_conservancy_areas_svw bcdata bc2pg -r whse_tantalis.ta_park_ecores_pa_svw +# DRA +mkdir -p tmp +# ** +# ** note temp dra data cache, to be replaced with new download location or a bc2pg download ** +# ** +#curl ftp://ftp.geobc.gov.bc.ca/sections/outgoing/bmgs/DRA_Public/dgtl_road_atlas.gdb.zip \ +# -o tmp/dgtl_road_atlas.gdb.zip +$PSQL -c "drop table if exists bcdata.transport_line" # in case of any failed loads +ogr2ogr \ + -f PostgreSQL \ + "PG:$DATABASE_URL" \ + --config PG_USE_COPY YES \ + -lco GEOMETRY_NAME=geom \ + -lco FID=transport_line_id \ + -nln bcdata.transport_line \ + /vsizip//vsicurl/https://bcfishpass.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/dgtl_road_atlas.gdb.zip \ + TRANSPORT_LINE +$PSQL -c "truncate whse_basemapping.transport_line; + insert into whse_basemapping.transport_line select * from bcdata.transport_line" +$PSQL -c "drop table bcdata.transport_line" + # parcel fabric, renaming download so it can be read without unzipping # ---- curl \ diff --git a/jobs/load_weekly b/jobs/load_weekly index 9170c7f1..b63bea0f 100755 --- a/jobs/load_weekly +++ b/jobs/load_weekly @@ -36,21 +36,3 @@ ogr2ogr -f PostgreSQL \ -nln cabd.waterfalls \ "https://cabd-web.azurewebsites.net/cabd-api/features/waterfalls?filter=province_territory_code:eq:bc&filter=use_analysis:eq:true" \ OGRGeoJSON - -# DRA -mkdir -p tmp -curl ftp://ftp.geobc.gov.bc.ca/sections/outgoing/bmgs/DRA_Public/dgtl_road_atlas.gdb.zip \ - -o tmp/dgtl_road_atlas.gdb.zip -$PSQL -c "drop table if exists bcdata.transport_line" # in case of any failed loads -ogr2ogr \ - -f PostgreSQL \ - "PG:$DATABASE_URL" \ - --config PG_USE_COPY YES \ - -lco GEOMETRY_NAME=geom \ - -lco FID=transport_line_id \ - -nln bcdata.transport_line \ - /vsizip/tmp/dgtl_road_atlas.gdb.zip \ - TRANSPORT_LINE -$PSQL -c "truncate whse_basemapping.transport_line; - insert into whse_basemapping.transport_line select * from bcdata.transport_line" -$PSQL -c "drop table bcdata.transport_line" From 3f260ec6d885e302f4f94d6a7f2dc51dc67fb2e8 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Simon Norris Date: Thu, 27 Jun 2024 09:31:34 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 4/7] incorporate @captainmarmot comments to habitat model doc --- docs/03_model_habitat_linear.md | 10 ++++++---- 1 file changed, 6 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/03_model_habitat_linear.md b/docs/03_model_habitat_linear.md index 93f949ed..8979d4b8 100644 --- a/docs/03_model_habitat_linear.md +++ b/docs/03_model_habitat_linear.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ (linear_habitat)= # Linear spawning/rearing habitat model -Streams accessible to fish may be suitable for spawning or rearing, or may only be used as movement corridors to reach such habitats. When estimating fragmentation and prioritizing further work, the amount of usable spawning or rearing habitat (habitat quality) is of greater interest than the raw amount of corridor habitat. In addition to modelling barriers to fish passage, `bcfishpass` can model the intrinsic potential (IP) of streams to support spawning or rearing activities for several species (Pacific Salmon, Steelhead, Bull Trout, Westslope Cutthroat Trout). +Streams accessible to fish may be suitable for spawning or rearing, or may only be used as movement corridors to reach such habitats. When estimating fragmentation and prioritizing further work, the amount of potential spawning or rearing habitat is of greater interest than the raw amount of corridor habitat. In addition to modelling barriers to fish passage, `bcfishpass` can model the intrinsic potential (IP) of streams to support spawning or rearing activities for several species (Pacific Salmon, Steelhead, Bull Trout, Westslope Cutthroat Trout). Linear spawning/rearing habitat modelling is currently based on species specific criteria for: @@ -43,10 +43,12 @@ Channel width is modelled for all of BC: - [Poisson Consulting](https://www.poissonconsulting.ca/temporary-hidden-link/859859031/channel-width-21b/) model based on upstream area / precipitation - [data collection/preparation](https://github.com/smnorris/fwapg/tree/main/extras/channel_width) -**NOTE** contributing area (FWA watersheds) and precipitiation (ClimateBC) datasets used to model discharge / channel width are both cut off at the BC border: +**NOTES** -- *all results from the above models are only valid for streams with 100% of their contributing area with BC* -- *streams with contributing area outside of BC (and thus with invalid spawning/rearing models) ARE NOT CURRENTLY NOTED in model outputs/file distributions* +1. Discharge and channel width models are based on historic climate data +2. Contributing area (FWA watersheds) and precipitiation (ClimateBC) datasets used to model discharge / channel width are both cut off at the BC border: + - *all results from the above models are only valid for streams with 100% of their contributing area with BC* + - *streams with contributing area outside of BC (and thus with invalid spawning/rearing models) ARE NOT CURRENTLY NOTED in model outputs/file distributions* From e97333c233923a25edafefd13efa5d4f3d66c86f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: matthewcooper11 <142512774+matthewcooper11@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Thu, 27 Jun 2024 13:11:19 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 5/7] Trib-by-Trib review updates Updates for the Bonaparte, Eagle and Bessette based on local knowledge --- data/user_habitat_classification.csv | 8 ++++++++ data/user_modelled_crossing_fixes.csv | 7 +++++++ 2 files changed, 15 insertions(+) diff --git a/data/user_habitat_classification.csv b/data/user_habitat_classification.csv index f78823e2..2beb0ed0 100644 --- a/data/user_habitat_classification.csv +++ b/data/user_habitat_classification.csv @@ -15248,6 +15248,7 @@ 360887120,20,120,TSAY,SK,spawning,t,SN,2023-09-01,Pacific Salmon Foundation,source point snapped to closest stream within 250m 360887414,204,304,KITL,SK,spawning,t,SN,2023-09-01,Pacific Salmon Foundation,source point snapped to closest stream within 250m 360879788,0,100,NASC,SK,spawning,t,SN,2023-09-01,Pacific Salmon Foundation,manually matched +<<<<<<< HEAD 360804808,253,527.036659,BULK,CH,spawning,t,LB,2024-06-06,Pacific Salmon Foundation,"PSE point is not located on a modelled stream, closest modelled stream line to PSE point was selected." 360864873,633,937,BULK,CO,spawning,t,LB,2024-06-06,Pacific Salmon Foundation, 360864873,1218.44764,1570,BULK,CO,spawning,t,LB,2024-06-06,Pacific Salmon Foundation, @@ -15295,3 +15296,10 @@ 360873822,168869,170329.9685,BULK,SK,spawning,t,LB,2024-06-06,Pacific Salmon Foundation,River sockeye 360881038,0,280.2148356,BULK,SK,spawning,t,LB,2024-06-06,Pacific Salmon Foundation,Lake sockeye 360804115,652.18,852.93,BULK,CO,spawning,t,LB,2024-06-17,Pacific Salmon Foundation, +356209928,25.6202005,486.7184822,SHUL,CO,Rearing,t,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,Local Knowledge -CO rearing habitati +356209928,486.719176,822,SHUL,CO,Spawning,t,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,Local Knowledge - CO Spawning +356343800,0,838,SHUL,SK,Spawning,t,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,Local Knowledge - CO and SK Spawning +356348431,1481,1681,SHUL,SK,Rearing,t,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,Local Knowledge - Some SK seen 300m upstream +356348431,1481,1781,SHUL,SK,Spawning,t,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,Local Knowledge - Some SK seen 300m upstream +356137288,265.6052138,408,SHUL,SK,Spawning,t,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,Local Knowledge - Adult SK observed up to rail line +356347377,0,558,BONP,CH,Spawning,t,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,Local Knowledge - major spawning for CH \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/user_modelled_crossing_fixes.csv b/data/user_modelled_crossing_fixes.csv index 29a204a3..740fe4b3 100644 --- a/data/user_modelled_crossing_fixes.csv +++ b/data/user_modelled_crossing_fixes.csv @@ -6163,6 +6163,7 @@ modelled_crossing_id,structure,watershed_group_code,reviewer_name,review_date,so 3700192,NONE,CRKD,AI,2024-01-02,Bing/Google/ESRI, no structure 6800484,NONE,HORS,MC,2024-03-14,DWB field assessments 2023,no structure found during assessment 6801356,NONE,HORS,MC,2024-03-14,DWB field assessments 2023,no structure found during assessment +<<<<<<< HEAD 11304215,NONE,LNIC,LB,2024-04-09,Field assessment,Comments indicate this crossing has been removed 11300428,NONE,LNIC,LB,2024-04-09,Imagery review, 11300427,NONE,LNIC,LB,2024-04-09,Imagery review, @@ -21680,3 +21681,9 @@ modelled_crossing_id,structure,watershed_group_code,reviewer_name,review_date,so 11304259,OBS,LNIC,LB,2024-06-11,Bing/Google/ESRI imagery, 11302218,FORD,LNIC,LB,2024-06-12,Bing/Google/ESRI imagery, 11302231,FORD,LNIC,LB,2024-06-13,Bing/Google/ESRI imagery, +1400002,NONE,BONP,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,Local Knowledge - Road no longer exists +18300020,CBS,SHUL,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,Local Knowledge - Replaced with new CBS in summer 2023 +18303484,CBS,SHUL,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,Local Knowledge - Barrier confirmed +18303506,OBS,SHUL,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,Local Knowledge - Fish getting past this structure (Bridge) +1400589,CBS,BONP,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,Local Knowledge - Culvert is Barrier +1400042,CBS,BONP,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,"Local Knowledge - Two poorly installed culverts, Barrier. Entire Creek is groundwater" \ No newline at end of file From ef8381af960ed8b7aea432f99870fcd921573186 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: matthewcooper11 <142512774+matthewcooper11@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Thu, 27 Jun 2024 13:47:57 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 6/7] ELKR data updates --- data/pscis_modelledcrossings_streams_xref.csv | 2 + data/user_modelled_crossing_fixes.csv | 11 +++++- data/user_pscis_barrier_status.csv | 37 ++++++++++++++++++- 3 files changed, 47 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/data/pscis_modelledcrossings_streams_xref.csv b/data/pscis_modelledcrossings_streams_xref.csv index 84ba138d..35bb6ea9 100644 --- a/data/pscis_modelledcrossings_streams_xref.csv +++ b/data/pscis_modelledcrossings_streams_xref.csv @@ -3562,3 +3562,5 @@ stream_crossing_id,modelled_crossing_id,linear_feature_id,watershed_group_code,r 198883,11303791,,LNIC,LB,Matched to closest modelled crossing. 198881,11300797,,LNIC,LB,Matched to closest modelled crossing. 198882,11303627,,LNIC,LB,Matched to closest modelled crossing. +197180,,701418136,HORS,MC,"PSCIS point is on a driveway with no modelled crossing, snapping point to nearest stream " +197571,4600316,,ELKR,MC,satellite imagery shows stream flowing to north before crossing under road. Matched PSCIS 197571 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/user_modelled_crossing_fixes.csv b/data/user_modelled_crossing_fixes.csv index 740fe4b3..91cddff7 100644 --- a/data/user_modelled_crossing_fixes.csv +++ b/data/user_modelled_crossing_fixes.csv @@ -21686,4 +21686,13 @@ modelled_crossing_id,structure,watershed_group_code,reviewer_name,review_date,so 18303484,CBS,SHUL,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,Local Knowledge - Barrier confirmed 18303506,OBS,SHUL,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,Local Knowledge - Fish getting past this structure (Bridge) 1400589,CBS,BONP,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,Local Knowledge - Culvert is Barrier -1400042,CBS,BONP,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,"Local Knowledge - Two poorly installed culverts, Barrier. Entire Creek is groundwater" \ No newline at end of file +1400042,CBS,BONP,MC,2024-06-27,Local Knowledge,"Local Knowledge - Two poorly installed culverts, Barrier. Entire Creek is groundwater" +4603156,NONE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,imagery,South Line Creek runs parallel to road in satellite imagery. Crossing does not exist. Remove. +4603391,NONE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,imagery,no sign of crossing on satellite imagery. Site of a landslide. Remove? +4603392,NONE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,imagery,no sign of crossing on satellite imagery. Remove? +4603432,NONE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,BC Parks,Confirmed by BC Parks to not exist. Recreational trail erroneously mapped in DRA. Remove crossing from model +4603971,NONE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,imagery,no sign of crossing on satellite imagery. Remove? +4604464,NONE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,imagery,South Line Creek runs parallel road in satellite imagery. Crossing does not exist. Remove. +24734832,NONE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,BC Parks,Confirmed by BC Parks to not exist. Recreational trail erroneously mapped in DRA. Remove crossing from model +4605600,OBS,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,imagery,bridge +4603974,NONE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,imagery,No crossing visible \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/user_pscis_barrier_status.csv b/data/user_pscis_barrier_status.csv index 295a8ffd..45899aaf 100644 --- a/data/user_pscis_barrier_status.csv +++ b/data/user_pscis_barrier_status.csv @@ -734,7 +734,7 @@ stream_crossing_id,user_barrier_status,watershed_group_code,reviewer_name,review 50258,PASSABLE,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) 50260,BARRIER,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) 50261,BARRIER,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) -50263,POTENTIAL,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,NJO - based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) +50263,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-03-27,Ford crossing based on assessment 50264,PASSABLE,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,NJO - based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) 50265,POTENTIAL,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) 50266,POTENTIAL,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) @@ -784,7 +784,7 @@ stream_crossing_id,user_barrier_status,watershed_group_code,reviewer_name,review 61632,PASSABLE,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) 61635,PASSABLE,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) 61636,PASSABLE,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,NJO - Flag for review - based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) -61637,BARRIER,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) +61637,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-03-26,Assessment states that this is not a barrier 62123,PASSABLE,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) 62134,PASSABLE,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) 62135,PASSABLE,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) @@ -1321,3 +1321,36 @@ stream_crossing_id,user_barrier_status,watershed_group_code,reviewer_name,review 196223,PASSABLE,TABR,SN,2024-06-03,Imagery clearly shows crossing has been remediated with a bridge installation 197664,POTENTIAL,BULK,LB,2024-06-13,Updated to potential barrier for CWF WCRP reporting 197665,POTENTIAL,BULK,LB,2024-06-13,Updated to potential barrier for CWF WCRP reporting +197823,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197824,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197826,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197563,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197803,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197805,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197816,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197818,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197819,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197820,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197821,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197822,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197846,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197847,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197831,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197837,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197838,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197839,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197788,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197789,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197790,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197791,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197801,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197804,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197797,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197808,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197811,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197841,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197856,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197858,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +197860,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,Ford crossing based on assessment +62245,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,This crossing has been rehabilitated +62293,POTENTIAL,ELKR,MC,2024-06-27,"Channel blew out and formed a new channel through road. Not clear if this ""ford"" is passable." \ No newline at end of file From 34c06804f3d626cfcf86499a9662a11053df3dd1 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Simon Norris Date: Fri, 28 Jun 2024 10:14:34 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 7/7] remove redundant record --- data/user_pscis_barrier_status.csv | 1 - 1 file changed, 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/data/user_pscis_barrier_status.csv b/data/user_pscis_barrier_status.csv index 45899aaf..1c9b3654 100644 --- a/data/user_pscis_barrier_status.csv +++ b/data/user_pscis_barrier_status.csv @@ -784,7 +784,6 @@ stream_crossing_id,user_barrier_status,watershed_group_code,reviewer_name,review 61632,PASSABLE,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) 61635,PASSABLE,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) 61636,PASSABLE,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,NJO - Flag for review - based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) -61637,PASSABLE,ELKR,MC,2024-03-26,Assessment states that this is not a barrier 62123,PASSABLE,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) 62134,PASSABLE,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required) 62135,PASSABLE,ELKR,CWF,2021-01-01,based on assessment comments (and imagery review where required)