diff --git a/teachertool/src/components/CatalogModal.tsx b/teachertool/src/components/CatalogModal.tsx
index c196d1f89738..b8896cf91df6 100644
--- a/teachertool/src/components/CatalogModal.tsx
+++ b/teachertool/src/components/CatalogModal.tsx
@@ -7,6 +7,7 @@ import { Modal } from "react-common/components/controls/Modal";
 import { hideModal } from "../transforms/hideModal";
 import { addCriteriaToRubric } from "../transforms/addCriteriaToRubric";
 import { CatalogCriteria } from "../types/criteria";
+import { getSelectableCatalogCriteria } from "../state/helpers";
 
 interface IProps {}
 
@@ -53,6 +54,8 @@ export const CatalogModal: React.FC<IProps> = ({}) => {
         },
     ];
 
+    const selectableCatalogCriteria = getSelectableCatalogCriteria();
+
     return teacherTool.modal === "catalog-display" ? (
         <Modal
             className="catalog-modal"
@@ -60,7 +63,7 @@ export const CatalogModal: React.FC<IProps> = ({}) => {
             onClose={closeModal}
             actions={modalActions}
         >
-            {teacherTool.catalog?.map(criteria => {
+            {selectableCatalogCriteria.map(criteria => {
                 return (
                     criteria?.template && (
                         <Checkbox
diff --git a/teachertool/src/state/helpers.ts b/teachertool/src/state/helpers.ts
index 6dc5c16c4d95..1c4f180710a7 100644
--- a/teachertool/src/state/helpers.ts
+++ b/teachertool/src/state/helpers.ts
@@ -41,3 +41,19 @@ export function verifyRubricIntegrity(rubric: Rubric): {
     }
     return { valid: invalidCriteria.length === 0, validCriteria, invalidCriteria };
 }
+
+export function getSelectableCatalogCriteria(): CatalogCriteria[] {
+    const { state } = stateAndDispatch();
+
+    const usedCriteria = state.rubric.criteria.map(c => c.catalogCriteriaId) ?? [];
+
+    // Return a criteria as selectable if it has parameters (so it can be used multiple times in a rubric)
+    // or if it has not yet been used in the active rubric.
+    return (
+        state.catalog?.filter(
+            catalogCriteria =>
+                (catalogCriteria.parameters && catalogCriteria.parameters.length > 0) ||
+                !usedCriteria.includes(catalogCriteria.id)
+        ) ?? []
+    );
+}