This table has been moved to a Google Sheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1OwT7PPoXvfR4Xw2aYLNNMFssaKbL_6TcKtnITJ-hQzM/edit?usp=sharing
Please edit/suggest that spreadsheet.
There are a lot of them. Scroll to the right if you need to. The information in here needs more updating.
| x1 | WPS | Simple Serial # | DPP | BRSKI w/pre-registration | BRSKI with POP no pre-registration | BRSKI / THREAD | OCF | Alljoyn | Bluetooth | EAP-NOOB | Intel SDO | 3G/4G/5G | LoRaWAN | Zigbee |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Correct Network Selection | Beacon based on user action | Yes, based on "configurator" | Hunt | Hunt | SoftAP / Beacon | Yes | Via Manual Pairing | Hunt | Hunt | |||||
| Onboard without Internet Acces | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | ||
| Proof of ownership | No | No | No | Yes when linked to sales or system integrators | Yes when linked to sales or system integrators | Yes when linked to sales or system integrators | Yes | Yes | No | No | Yes | No | ||
| Supply chain security | No | No | No | MASA can be linked to supply chain management tools | MASA can be linked to supply chain management tools | No | No | No | No | No | ||||
| Hands free* | No | No | No | Yes when linked to sales or system integrators | No | Yes with a MASA | No | No | Not with proof of posession | No | Yes | Yes? | No | |
| Security model | Presumption of no other announcements | no | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No real PoP | Dynamic Code Gen | Yes | Label | ||||
| Status | Std | Std | In stream | Beginning | Std | Std | Std | Beginning | Std | |||||
| Key type | None | Ser # | Asym. | X.509 | X.509+private | Asym | Asym | Asym | Asym | Asym | Key+Label | |||
| Manufacturing complexity | Nvram | Serial# | Key+Label | Cert+Registration | Cert+label | Key+Label | Key+Label | Minimal | Dynamic Code Gen | SIM/SoftCIM | QR Code | |||
| Deployment Challenges | Not Secure | Not secure | No EAP linkage | Internet access | Scan required | Scan required and no EAP | No EAP linkage | SDO components | Label Management | |||||
| Who Implements | Lots | HPE | Siemens, Cisco, Sandelman | Siemens, NXP, Sandelman, SILABs | Everyone | Intel, ARM | ||||||||
| Reference |