[de] Generic question: "Is a light in an area on?"

[ChristophCaina]

Assist is not able to provide a clear YES / NO information if "a light" is on - without explicitly asking for the entity name / alias.

1. Only one LIGHT entity is available in our sleeping room.
   The question "Is the light in the sleeping room on?" - will be answered with NO - even if the light is on.
   

2. Turn the light ON / OFF in the sleepingroom is working, without providing the alias / entity name.
   The light will be turned on or off
   
   

3. After setting "Light" as an alias for this particular light, the question from above is working as expected
   

--> I would expect Assist to be able to provide a clear information "YES / NO" if ANY light is on in an area, without the need to ask for a specific entity / alias.

Asking the question in a different form is providing the correct information:

[tetele]

There's no such sentence in English (which is where all other languages draw inspiration from), but I don't see any reason not to add it.

Cancel that, the sentences exist in English and in German

[mib1185]

is this still valid?